Do low-carb diets reduce appetite more than low-fat diets? A new study suggests the answer is no. How do we reconcile that with other studies that say the opposite?
Let’s get into the details. 84 overweight subjects with diabetes were randomized to a diet with 14% of energy from carbs (labeled as less than 50 grams per day) or a diet with 53% of energy from carbs. Both diets were designed to create a 500-1,000 kcal deficit. Researchers limited both diets to less than 10% saturated fats. By default, that likely means a high proportion of the fat in the low-carb diet came from oils rather than whole foods which would contain more saturated fats (like meat, eggs, chicken, dairy).
After 16 weeks there did not appear to be much of a difference in hunger and satiety between the groups. The authors’ conclusions? Keto diets are no better than high-carb diets for hunger. This is in direct contrast to prior studies that suggest the opposite.
For example, a meta-analysis of studies comparing a ketogenic diet with “very low energy diets” showed those on the keto diets were less hungry and had less desire to eat. Another study showed a more beneficial effect on peptide YY suggesting satiety may be improved. And a third study showed obese men following a ketogenic diet (average BHB 1.5 mmol/L) had significantly less hunger than a moderate carb diet at four weeks.
In addition, our clinical expert panel unanimously agrees with the notion that ketogenic diets suppress hunger and make intermittent fasting easier on their patients.
So, why the difference? For one, this study was not a ketogenic diet study. The average BHB level was 0.2 mmol/L, not reaching the cut off for nutritional ketosis (0.5 mmol/L). As ketones are hypothesized to have appetite lowering effects, this makes a difference. In addition, the reduction in saturated fats likely eliminated many of the more satiating foods such as meat, and eggs. Clinical experience suggests fats from oils are far less hunger-suppressing than solid foods.
But this study is very interesting since many people do try to follow a similar “almost keto” diet. People may try to limit their saturated fats and they may not try to be in ketosis, but rather are happy to eat low-carb. While that still can have beneficial effects on weight loss and metabolic health, this study suggests it does not have an advantage over higher carb diets with respect to feeling full.
So, in the end, it depends on your goals. If you are looking for appetite suppression, it looks likes ketones and whole foods may make the difference.
Try it for yourself and see which way works better for your hunger and satiety!
Thanks for reading,
Bret Scher, MD FACC
KetoKeto for beginners: Introduction08:02Learn how to do a keto diet right, in part 1 of our video course.A ketogenic diet and fewer vegetables17:26Should you NOT eat your vegetables? An interview with psychiatrist Dr. Georgia Ede.How to formulate a low-carb keto diet48:32Low-carb pioneer Dr. Eric Westman talks about how to formulate an LCHF diet, low carb for different medical conditions and common pitfalls among others.Part 2 of eating keto with Kristie: Build a keto plate11:16Are you confused about what a plate of keto food should look like? Then this part of the course is for you.“I’ll do this or I’m going to die trying”19:23Kristie Sullivan struggled with her weight for her whole life in spite of trying every diet imaginable, but then she finally lost a 120 pounds and improved her health on a keto diet.Part 1 of eating keto with Kristie: Introduction01:47One of the hardest parts of starting a keto diet is figuring out what to eat. Fortunately, Kristie will teach you in this course.Part 3 of eating keto with Kristie: Know your portion sizes15:29Kristie teaches us how to eyeball the right amounts of fat, protein and carbs in order to ensure that we can easily stay within ketogenic ratios.Fat Chance1:05:43Is it possible to ride a pushbike across the Australian continent (2,100 miles) without eating carbs?Keto and fast food10:28Can you get low-carb food at fast-food restaurants? Ivor Cummins and Bjarte Bakke went to a number of fast-food restaurants to find out.Is lower insulin the key to better brain health?46:36What is the root cause of the Alzheimer’s epidemic – and how should we intervene before the disease is fully developed?Eating keto to survive cancer28:51Audra Wilford on the experience of using a ketogenic diet as part of treating her son Max’s brain tumor.Diet Doctor Podcast #31 – Dr. Ken Berry51:26Dr. Ken Berry wants us all to be aware that much of what our doctors say may be a lie. Maybe not an outright malicious lie, but much of what “we” believe in medicine can be traced back to word-of-mouth teachings without a scientific basis.Challenging the dogma16:47Dr. Priyanka Wali tried a ketogenic diet and felt great. After reviewing the science she started recommending it to patients.All things keto with Keto Connect16:44What is it like running the very popular YouTube channel Keto Connect?Exploiting cancer metabolism with ketosis44:42Can a ketogenic diet be used in cancer treatment? Dr. Angela Poff at the Low Carb USA 2016.A new life with a keto diet13:38If your muscles can’t use stored glycogen, is it then a good idea to eat a high-carb diet to compensate for this? Or can a keto diet help treat these rare glycogen storage diseases?A life without migraines15:44Elena Gross’ life was completely transformed with the ketogenic diet.Tips for eating out – part 5 of eating keto with Kristie10:10Do you find it difficult to stay on your keto plan when you’re dining out and still don’t want to miss out on those lovely moments with friends and family? Then this episode is for you.Diet Doctor Podcast #35 with Ben Bikman, PhD00:00Why is insulin so important for us to control and why does a ketogenic diet help so many people? Professor Ben Bikman has studied these questions in his lab for years and he is one of the foremost authorities on the subject.My success story with Jim Caldwell02:23Jim Caldwell has transformed his health and gone from an all-time high at 352 lbs (160 kg) to 170 lbs (77 kg.LCHF and diabetes: science and clinical experience45:59What is the root of the problem in type 2 diabetes? And how can we treat it? Dr. Eric Westman at the Low Carb USA 2016.Treating cancer with a keto diet17:07Can a strict keto diet help prevent or even treat some cancers, like brain cancer?How to lose 240 pounds without hunger31:06How to lose 240 pounds without hunger – Lynne Ivey and her incredible story.Low-carb living1:00:21How do you successfully eat low carb for life? And what’s the role of ketosis? Dr. Stephen Phinney answers these questions.
The post Low-carb and high-carb diets have similar effects on hunger appeared first on Diet Doctor.
Read more: dietdoctor.com